Open Benchmark Dataset · CC BY 4.0 · v2026.1.7

Specialty Trade Market Concentration & Review Skew

Empirical market concentration across 500,271 U.S. NAICS 238 specialty trade employer firms (2022 Census SUSB) and 111,261 public business-review listings: why revenue remains fragmented below 5% CR4 in HVAC and plumbing alongside electrical while metro consumer reviews concentrate up to 7.11x in the top decile.

500,271
U.S. NAICS 238 employer firms ($1,286.25B receipts, 2022 Census SUSB)
91.2%
NAICS 238 firms under 20 employees (89.9% HVAC/plumbing, 89.7% electrical)
4.1% to 5.1%
Four-firm share (CR4) across HVAC, plumbing, roofing, and electrical
3.38x / 7.11x
HVAC review mean/median and p90/median skew (n = 42,943 listings)

Machine-readable downloads: /data/market-concentration.json (full nested tables, citations, and metro rows) and /data/market-concentration.csv (flat 13-trade concentration and review-skew matrix). Licensed under CC BY 4.0 with attribution to TradesIndex by Level.

Operating margin, 85.1% median invoice collection rate, and DSO benchmarks across 2,242 contractors ($13.25B job revenue) are maintained on sibling property Level CFO.

1. NAICS 238 employer size & multi-branch concentration (2022 Census SUSB)

Federal employer records from the U.S. Census Bureau 2022 Statistics of U.S. Businesses (released April 2025) show why roll-up consolidators target specialty trades. Small shops with fewer than 20 employees represent 456,123 firms (91.2% of the employer count) and average 1.000 establishment per firm, capturing $415.92B (32.3%) of sector receipts. At the opposite end of the distribution, just 802 enterprise platforms with 500 or more employees (0.16% of firms) operate 6,822 branch establishments (8.51 locations per firm) and generate $226.66B (17.6%) of total NAICS 238 revenue.

Enterprise employment bandFirmsFirm shareEstablishmentsBranches / firmPaid employeesReceipts ($B)Receipt share
Total (NAICS 238)500,271100%510,8031.021x4,773,221$1286.25B100%
Under 5 employees322,26064.4%322,2741.000x520,672$130.84B10.2%
5 to 9 employees84,29416.8%84,3241.000x552,522$124.57B9.7%
10 to 19 employees49,5699.9%49,7141.003x665,219$160.51B12.5%
Subtotal: Under 20 employees456,12391.2%456,3121.000x1,738,413$415.92B32.3%
20 to 99 employees38,4937.7%40,1461.043x1,469,918$400.84B31.2%
100 to 499 employees4,8531%7,5231.550x825,023$242.83B18.9%
Subtotal: Under 500 employees499,46999.8%503,9811.009x4,033,354$1059.59B82.4%
500+ employees (Enterprise)8020.16%6,8228.506x739,867$226.66B17.6%

2. Trade-by-trade CR4, small-shop share & licensing barriers

SBA four-firm market concentration (CR4, derived from Economic Census special tabulations) stays under 8% in core trades including HVAC and plumbing (4.1%), roofing (4.4%), concrete (4.9%), electrical (5.1%), glazing (5.2%) plus painting (6.9%) and restoration (7.8%). Concentration climbs only where route-based national contracts or OEM equipment service branches dominate, reaching 11.2% CR4 in commercial cleaning, 24.7% in doors and building-equipment specialty work (NAICS 238290), and 57.2% 500-plus-employee receipt share in NAICS 561621 alarm and security systems.

Licensing rules reinforce those local moats across 37 to 48 states in MEP and life-safety trades.

TradePrimary NAICS2022 SUSB firmsBranches / firmUnder 20 emp500+ emp receiptsSBA CR4Licensed states
HVAC & Refrigeration238220 (shared with Plumbing)107,0041.024x89.9%21.9%4.1%37 / 50
Plumbing238220 (shared with HVAC)107,0041.024x89.9%21.9%4.1%44 / 50
Electrical23821079,6111.028x89.7%27.2%5.1%46 / 50
Roofing23816024,0441.020x90.8%7.1%4.4%34 / 50
Glass & Glazing2381506,5481.032x88.2%4.8%5.2%26 / 50
Doors & Access238290 (equipment & overhead doors)6,7211.176x82.8%41.5%24.7%29 / 50
Landscaping & Grounds561730114,8421.020x94.3%15.2%9.6%16 / 50
Commercial Cleaning & Janitorial56172062,9701.069x89%40.9%11.2%0 / 50
Painting & Wall Finishing23832037,8301.004x95.6%4%6.9%27 / 50
Concrete & Masonry238110 + 23814040,7991.009x90.5%14.2%4.9%31 / 50
Fire & Life Safety561621 (alarm & life-safety systems)5,7611.222x86.4%57.2%Withheld32 / 50
Low-Voltage & Security561621 (security & low-voltage systems)5,7611.222x86.4%57.2%Withheld48 / 50
Restoration & Remediation238990 (all other specialty trade)39,7841.013x92.9%12.3%7.8%46 / 50

3. Digital review concentration across 111,261 public listings

While revenue across HVAC and plumbing alongside electrical shops is dispersed across tens of thousands of local employers, online customer reviews exhibit steep power-law concentration. Across 111,261 scanned public business-review listings (111,014 mapped to a primary trade; six trades meeting the n = 200 publication threshold), top-decile operators capture 4.67x to 7.11x the review count of the median shop. Because review culture differs sharply across states and metro markets, evaluating an operator on a single national curve misranks 30.4% to 38.6% of active shops by more than 10 percentile points.

TradeListings (n)Median ratingReviews p25 / p50 / p75 / p90Mean reviewsMean / p50 skewp90 / p50 skewClaimed %State misrank
HVAC & Refrigeration42,9434.04 / 9 / 23 / 6430.433.38x7.11x77.2%36.7%
Plumbing11,7484.23 / 7 / 16 / 4118.892.70x5.86x68.7%37.3%
Electrical12,5344.63 / 6 / 14 / 3918.353.06x6.50x74.5%38.1%
Roofing22,7964.03 / 6 / 12 / 2913.752.29x4.83x77.9%30.4%
Landscaping & Grounds20,0193.93 / 6 / 12 / 2813.652.28x4.67x67.5%38.6%
Fire & Life Safety9633.73 / 5 / 11 / 2513.032.61x5.00x71.9%Below floor

4. Metro employer concentration & city review skew

Geographic density compounds local digital concentration. Four states (California and Florida alongside Texas and New York) account for 31.8% of U.S. NAICS 238 establishments and $430.34B (33.5%) of national specialty trade receipts. At the metro level, New York-Newark-Jersey City leads with 30,190 NAICS 238 employer firms ($73.51B receipts). Among the 22 cities with at least 350 mapped listings, Phoenix (3.92x), San Diego (3.79x), plus San Francisco (3.66x) show the widest mean-to-median review skew.

Top 10 U.S. metropolitan areas for NAICS 238 contractors (2022 Census SUSB)

RankMetropolitan statistical area (MSA)FirmsEstablishmentsPaid employeesEstimated receipts ($B)
1New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ30,19030,334246,006$73.51B
2Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim, CA15,02515,158168,898$42.00B
3Chicago-Naperville-Elgin, IL-IN14,14514,252116,340$37.42B
4Miami-Fort Lauderdale-West Palm Beach, FL11,60011,66885,873$22.60B
5Dallas-Fort Worth-Arlington, TX9,4799,584127,353$37.73B
6Boston-Cambridge-Newton, MA-NH9,2499,30081,864$26.23B
7Philadelphia-Camden-Wilmington, PA-NJ-DE-MD8,8908,96083,526$24.54B
8Atlanta-Sandy Springs-Roswell, GA8,2908,36190,200$32.35B
9Seattle-Tacoma-Bellevue, WA8,0638,11883,457$22.24B
10Washington-Arlington-Alexandria, DC-VA-MD-WV7,9148,033105,854$30.44B

City-level review concentration (22 cities with n >= 350 listings)

CityListings (n)Avg ratingMedian reviewsMean reviewsMean / median skew
Los Angeles, CA1,1024.341550.433.36x
Houston, TX8983.67619.873.31x
San Diego, CA8334.301660.703.79x
Phoenix, AZ7823.921039.233.92x
Las Vegas, NV7523.951859.143.29x
Austin, TX7364.001237.293.11x
San Jose, CA7124.292160.292.87x
Chicago, IL6273.911138.683.52x
San Antonio, TX6083.81615.972.66x
Denver, CO4793.66825.903.24x
Tucson, AZ4713.79920.432.27x
Sacramento, CA4564.061550.543.37x
Mesa, AZ4244.011126.062.37x
San Francisco, CA4124.401658.483.66x
Dallas, TX3983.63718.902.70x
Miami, FL3903.66614.342.39x
Colorado Springs, CO3783.65713.621.95x
Seattle, WA3774.111343.903.38x
Portland, OR3733.881329.682.28x
Jacksonville, FL3683.40613.862.31x
Tampa, FL3553.40719.102.73x
Brooklyn, NY3533.79718.422.63x

Frequently asked questions

How fragmented is the U.S. specialty trade contracting market by firm size?

In the 2022 U.S. Census Bureau Statistics of U.S. Businesses (SUSB) for NAICS 238 Specialty Trade Contractors, 456,123 of 500,271 employer firms (91.2%) employ fewer than 20 workers, including 89.9% in NAICS 238220 (plumbing and HVAC) and 89.7% in NAICS 238210 (electrical). In HVAC contracting specifically, no single operator holds 5% national market share.

Why is consumer review volume concentrated even when contractor revenue is fragmented?

Across 111,261 scanned public business-review listings, digital visibility concentrates heavily in the top decile. In HVAC (n = 42,943), median review volume is 9 reviews while the mean reaches 30.43 (3.38x skew) and the 90th percentile reaches 64 reviews (7.11x the median).

How many branches do enterprise specialty trade platforms operate?

In 2022 Census SUSB data for NAICS 238, the 802 enterprise firms with 500 or more employees (0.16% of employer firms) operate 6,822 establishments, averaging 8.51 locations per firm and generating $226.66B (17.6%) of sector receipts.

Why does benchmarking contractor reviews against a single national curve fail across states and metros?

Review density varies sharply by metro and state. Comparing active contractors against a single national percentile curve misranks 30.4% to 38.6% of operating businesses by more than 10 percentile points across roofing, HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and landscaping.

Primary federal & industry citations

Explore the full open dataset, review specialty trade valuation multiples, compare multi-entity ERPs on Dynamics 365 BC vs. Sage Intacct vs. Acumatica, or inspect all 13 scored trade profiles.